Grammarly vs ProWritingAid for Authors: A Detailed Comparison of Writing Assistants

I spent three months editing my last novel draft, convinced I was a grammar wizard, before my beta readers handed it back with more red ink than a butcher’s shop. That’s when I realized I needed help. I tried both Grammarly and ProWritingAid, hoping to catch the embarrassing mistakes before anyone else did. Here’s what I wish I’d known.

Grammarly: The Quick Fixer with a Gentle Hand

Verdict: Grammarly is excellent for quick, confident fixes, especially for non-fiction or short-form content. For authors, it’s a good first pass, but it won’t catch everything you need.

I started with Grammarly Premium. The main reason? Everyone talks about it. It’s super easy to use, and it integrates almost everywhere. I installed the browser extension, the desktop app, and even the add-in for Microsoft Word. It just… works. As I typed, suggestions popped up in real-time. Green underlines for grammar, blue for clarity, purple for style.

What I liked most was the clarity suggestions. It often pointed out passive voice or wordy sentences. For my blog posts and marketing copy, this was a lifesaver. It made my non-fiction much tighter and more professional. The tone detector was also surprisingly helpful for making sure my emails sounded right – not too aggressive, not too passive.

However, when I put my novel manuscript through it, I started to see its limits. Grammarly is great at catching outright errors – misplaced commas, subject-verb agreement issues, basic spelling. But it struggled with the nuances of creative writing. It often flagged legitimate stylistic choices as errors, like intentional sentence fragments for dramatic effect, or dialogue that didn’t conform to standard grammar. I found myself dismissing many suggestions, which made me wonder if I was missing genuine problems.

Specific features: Real-time grammar and spelling checks, clarity suggestions, conciseness suggestions, tone detection, plagiarism checker (which I never actually used for my fiction). It connects directly to Microsoft Word, Google Docs, and has a great browser extension for web-based writing.

Real Pricing: Grammarly Premium is $30/month if you pay monthly, or about $12/month if you pay for a year upfront ($144/year). For authors, the annual plan is the only one that makes sense. The free version is good for basic proofreading but lacks the depth for serious writing.

ProWritingAid: The Author’s Deep Dive

Verdict: ProWritingAid is the clear winner for authors. It offers a much deeper analysis of writing style and common fiction pitfalls, even if its interface is a bit clunkier.

After Grammarly left me wanting more for my novel, I switched to ProWritingAid. The difference was immediate. Where Grammarly was a quick spell-check, ProWritingAid was a full-blown diagnostic tool. It felt like having a dozen mini-editors looking at different aspects of my writing.

The number of reports is staggering. Beyond basic grammar, it has reports for sticky sentences (wordy phrases), overuse of adverbs, repeated words and phrases, pacing, dialogue tags, clichés, and even “dangling participles.” For a fiction writer, this depth is invaluable. It helped me identify my specific writing crutches – my tendency to start too many sentences with “He was” or my reliance on weak verbs.

I uploaded my entire manuscript chapter by chapter. The learning curve was a bit steeper than Grammarly. Instead of real-time suggestions, you run reports. You click on “Summary Report” or “Pacing Report,” and it generates a detailed analysis. This meant less distraction while writing, but more time dedicated to the editing phase. It highlights issues, explains why they’re issues, and often suggests alternatives. For example, its “Overused Words” report was brilliant for flagging my pet words I didn’t even realize I was repeating.

One of my favorite features was the “Dictionary and Thesaurus” integration. You can right-click any word to get synonyms, which is helpful when you’re trying to vary your vocabulary without pulling out of your writing flow. The “Consistency Check” was also great for catching things like hyphenation differences or inconsistent capitalization of character names – tiny details that make a huge difference in professionalism.

It’s not as slick as Grammarly. The interface feels a bit dated, and the real-time checking in its desktop app or integrations can be slower. Sometimes it would freeze up Word for a few seconds when processing a large document. But the sheer utility for authors outweighs these minor frustrations.

Specific features: Over 20 different reports including: Grammar and spelling, style, readability, sticky sentences, adverbs, dialogue tags, pacing, clichés, sentence length variety, transition words, consistency checker, repeated phrases, contextual thesaurus. It integrates with Microsoft Word, Scrivener, Google Docs (via browser extension), and has a desktop app.

Real Pricing: ProWritingAid Premium is $30/month if paid monthly, or $10/month if paid annually ($120/year). They also offer a lifetime license for $399, which is what I eventually bought because I knew I’d be writing for years. For authors, the lifetime license is a no-brainer if you’re serious.

Comparison and My Recommendation

For general writing, emails, social media, or even blog posts, Grammarly is quick, clean, and effective. It’s like a good general practitioner – catches the common stuff, gives you solid advice. If you mostly write non-fiction and want to improve clarity and conciseness without getting bogged down in too much detail, Grammarly is perfectly adequate.

For authors, especially fiction writers, ProWritingAid is the superior tool. It’s like having a dedicated editor specializing in the specific craft of storytelling. It dives deep into narrative issues, character voice, and the flow of your prose in a way Grammarly simply doesn’t attempt. Yes, the interface isn’t as polished, and it requires a different workflow (running reports instead of real-time nagging), but the insights it provides are invaluable for polishing a manuscript.

You could theoretically use both. Use Grammarly for your initial draft and quick checks, then run your manuscript through ProWritingAid for the deep stylistic editing. However, I found that ProWritingAid’s grammar checks were good enough that Grammarly became redundant once I committed to the deeper dive.

What to sign up for today: If you are an author writing novels, short stories, or creative non-fiction, sign up for ProWritingAid Premium Annual ($120/year). Use it for a year, learn its features, and if you’re serious about writing, upgrade to the lifetime license during a sale. If you mostly write professional emails, blog posts, or academic papers, sign up for Grammarly Premium Annual ($144/year).

Frequently Asked Questions